Our new X account is live! Follow @wizwand_team for updates
WorkDL logo mark

Concept Embedding Models: Beyond the Accuracy-Explainability Trade-Off

About

Deploying AI-powered systems requires trustworthy models supporting effective human interactions, going beyond raw prediction accuracy. Concept bottleneck models promote trustworthiness by conditioning classification tasks on an intermediate level of human-like concepts. This enables human interventions which can correct mispredicted concepts to improve the model's performance. However, existing concept bottleneck models are unable to find optimal compromises between high task accuracy, robust concept-based explanations, and effective interventions on concepts -- particularly in real-world conditions where complete and accurate concept supervisions are scarce. To address this, we propose Concept Embedding Models, a novel family of concept bottleneck models which goes beyond the current accuracy-vs-interpretability trade-off by learning interpretable high-dimensional concept representations. Our experiments demonstrate that Concept Embedding Models (1) attain better or competitive task accuracy w.r.t. standard neural models without concepts, (2) provide concept representations capturing meaningful semantics including and beyond their ground truth labels, (3) support test-time concept interventions whose effect in test accuracy surpasses that in standard concept bottleneck models, and (4) scale to real-world conditions where complete concept supervisions are scarce.

Mateo Espinosa Zarlenga, Pietro Barbiero, Gabriele Ciravegna, Giuseppe Marra, Francesco Giannini, Michelangelo Diligenti, Zohreh Shams, Frederic Precioso, Stefano Melacci, Adrian Weller, Pietro Lio, Mateja Jamnik• 2022

Related benchmarks

TaskDatasetResultRank
Image ClassificationCIFAR100
Accuracy81.23
331
Image ClassificationCUB
Accuracy80.47
249
ClassificationCelebA
Avg Accuracy30.63
137
ClassificationCUB
Accuracy79.029
85
ClassificationCUB (test)
Accuracy79
79
Image ClassificationImageNet
Accuracy81.29
47
Task Predictive PerformanceMNIST-Add (test)
Accuracy96.68
28
Task Predictive PerformanceMNIST-Add-Incomp (test)
Accuracy/AUC87.58
24
Image ClassificationCaltech-UCSD Birds (CUB-200-2011) (test)
Accuracy82.5
22
ClassificationAWA2 (test)--
22
Showing 10 of 46 rows

Other info

Code

Follow for update