LLMScore: Unveiling the Power of Large Language Models in Text-to-Image Synthesis Evaluation
About
Existing automatic evaluation on text-to-image synthesis can only provide an image-text matching score, without considering the object-level compositionality, which results in poor correlation with human judgments. In this work, we propose LLMScore, a new framework that offers evaluation scores with multi-granularity compositionality. LLMScore leverages the large language models (LLMs) to evaluate text-to-image models. Initially, it transforms the image into image-level and object-level visual descriptions. Then an evaluation instruction is fed into the LLMs to measure the alignment between the synthesized image and the text, ultimately generating a score accompanied by a rationale. Our substantial analysis reveals the highest correlation of LLMScore with human judgments on a wide range of datasets (Attribute Binding Contrast, Concept Conjunction, MSCOCO, DrawBench, PaintSkills). Notably, our LLMScore achieves Kendall's tau correlation with human evaluations that is 58.8% and 31.2% higher than the commonly-used text-image matching metrics CLIP and BLIP, respectively.
Related benchmarks
| Task | Dataset | Result | Rank | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Text-to-image synthesis evaluation (Human Correlation - Overall) | DrawBench | Kendall's Tau0.223 | 19 | |
| Text-to-image synthesis evaluation (Human Correlation - Overall) | PaintSkills | Kendall's Tau0.6437 | 19 | |
| Human Correlation Analysis for Text-to-Image Synthesis | Composition-focused Prompt Bench Concept Conjunction (Stable Diffusion) | Kendall's Tau0.4871 | 10 | |
| Human Correlation Analysis for Text-to-Image Synthesis | Composition-focused Prompt Bench Concept Conjunction DALL-E | Kendall's Tau0.5167 | 10 | |
| Human Correlation Analysis for Text-to-Image Synthesis | Composition-focused Prompt Bench Attribute Binding Contrast Stable Diffusion | Kendall's Tau0.4005 | 10 | |
| Human Correlation Analysis for Text-to-Image Synthesis | Composition-focused Prompt Bench Attribute Binding Contrast DALL-E | Kendall's Tau0.3955 | 10 | |
| Text-to-image synthesis evaluation | COCO 2014 | Kendall's Tau (τ)0.3629 | 10 | |
| Text-to-image synthesis evaluation | COCO 2017 | Kendall's Tau0.3357 | 10 | |
| Text-to-image synthesis evaluation (Human Correlation - Error Counting) | COCO 2014 | Kendall's Tau0.2792 | 9 | |
| Text-to-image synthesis evaluation (Human Correlation - Error Counting) | COCO 2017 | Kendall's Tau0.2138 | 9 |