Share your thoughts, 1 month free Claude Pro on usSee more
WorkDL logo mark

When Does a Language Model Commit? A Finite-Answer Theory of Pre-Verbalization Commitment

About

Language models often generate reasoning before giving a final answer, but the visible answer does not reveal when the model's answer preference became stable. We study this question through a narrow computable object: \emph{finite-answer preference stabilization}. For a model state and specified answer verbalizers, we project the model's own continuation probabilities onto a finite answer set; in binary tasks this yields an exact log-odds code, $\delta(\xi)=S_\theta(\mathrm{yes}\mid\xi)-S_\theta(\mathrm{no}\mid\xi)$. This target defines parser-based answer onset, retrospective stabilization time, and lead without relying on greedy rollouts or learned probes. In controlled delayed-verdict tasks with Qwen3-4B-Instruct, the contextual finite-answer projection stabilizes before the answer is parseable, with 17--31 token mean lead in the main templates and positive, shorter lead in a parser-clean replication. The signal tracks the model's eventual output rather than truth, is linearly recoverable from compact hidden summaries, is partly separable from cursor progress, and transfers as shared information without a single invariant coordinate. Diagnostics separate the measurement from online stopping, verbalizer-free belief, and causal answer control; exact steering shows local sensitivity of $\delta$ but not reliable generation control.

Long Zhang, Wei-neng Chen, Feng-feng Wei, Zi-bo Qin• 2026

Related benchmarks

TaskDatasetResultRank
Finite-answer lead measurementQuality-gated parser-clean replication dataset v1 (test)
Parse Accuracy100
4
Pre-verbalization preference stabilizationQwen Evaluation Suite Prompt shift Qwen3
Accuracy100
2
Pre-verbalization preference stabilizationQwen3 Evaluation Suite Canonical
Accuracy100
1
Pre-verbalization preference stabilizationQwen3 Evaluation Suite Verbalizer shift
Accuracy100
1
Showing 4 of 4 rows

Other info

Follow for update