GEOPHYS: The Geometry of Physical Plausibility
About
While humans can identify physically implausible events within milliseconds, machine learning approaches addressing the same problem are extremely slow and expensive. They either rely on external multimodal-LLM judges or require ad-hoc modifications to the training procedure. In this work, we argue that indicators of physical plausibility are implicitly captured by five geometric properties of the per-frame embeddings produced by frozen image encoders. In aggregate, we call them GEOPHYS. First, we show that these signals correlate with human EEG responses to two forms of object-permanence violations. Second, GEOPHYS robustly discriminates physically implausible videos from realistic ones, achieving state-of-the-art physics-violation detection: 98.3% on LikePhys and 93.3% on IntPhys2, whereas V-JEPA 2, GPT-4o, Gemini, and twelve modern video diffusion models perform near chance. Third, used as a best-of-N verifier for physical alignment during video generation, GEOPHYS lifts MAGI-1 24B from 50.01% to 64.50% on PhysicsIQ at 1.5x lower wall-clock and 4.65x lower memory than the V-JEPA 2 world-model verifier. Ultimately, GEOPHYS demonstrates that physical plausibility in videos can be assessed by leveraging the emergent geometric properties of temporal features extracted from image encoders.
Related benchmarks
| Task | Dataset | Result | Rank | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Intuitive Physics Understanding | LikePhys 1.0 (test) | PPE: Ball Collision100 | 32 | |
| Physics violation detection | IntPhys 2 | Mean Accuracy93.3 | 17 | |
| Physical Plausibility Verification | PhysicsIQ MAGI-1 24B I2V (N=16) | Spatial IoU27.6 | 7 | |
| Physical Plausibility Verification | PhysicsIQ MAGI-1 24B V2V N=16 | Spatial IoU47.2 | 7 | |
| Video Quality Evaluation | PhysicsIQ V2V | PhyIQ64.5 | 7 | |
| Physical Plausibility Verification | PhysicsIQ MAGI-1 4.5B I2V (N=16) | Spatial IoU22.5 | 7 | |
| Physical Plausibility Verification | PhysicsIQ Wan2.1 14B I2V (N=16) | Spatial IoU22.5 | 7 | |
| Physical Plausibility Verification | PhysicsIQ CogVideoX-5B I2V (N=16) | Spatial IoU0.225 | 7 | |
| Neural signal alignment detection | Balaban Permanence | Pairwise Accuracy2 | 6 | |
| Neural signal alignment detection | Liu Permanence | Pairwise Accuracy6 | 6 |