Probing the Misaligned Thinking Process of Language Models
About
Large language models exhibit a growing range of misaligned behaviors such as strategic deception, sandbagging, and self-preservation. As they are increasingly deployed in high-stakes settings, it is critical to reliably detect such behaviors to ensure safe and responsible use. In this work, we propose to monitor misalignment by decomposing it into fine-grained cognitive processes -- misalignment indicators -- and detecting their presence in a model's internal activations via linear probes. We develop a taxonomy of 18 indicators spanning different misaligned behaviors, paired with an automated, meta-plan-guided pipeline that generates multi-turn training conversations. To rigorously evaluate generalization, we construct an out-of-distribution suite combining automated behavioral elicitation, established misalignment benchmarks, and natural benign conversations. Across 5 misaligned behaviors, our probes match a strong LLM judge with 0.935 AUROC on out-of-distribution benchmarks while keeping a low false positive rate on benign traffic. We further perform in-depth analysis to understand the probes and the model's internal representations of misalignment indicators.
Related benchmarks
| Task | Dataset | Result | Rank | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Misalignment monitoring | Misalignment Monitoring Dataset (dev) | AUROC (Deception)0.926 | 6 | |
| Misalignment monitoring | Misalignment Monitoring Dataset (test) | AUROC (Deception)94.6 | 6 | |
| Misalignment Detection | Covert code sabotage Bloom behaviors (in-distribution) | AUROC0.959 | 4 | |
| Misalignment Detection | Strategic sandbagging Bloom behaviors (in-distribution) | AUROC0.985 | 4 | |
| Misalignment Detection | Self-preservation Bloom behaviors (in-distribution) | AUROC95.6 | 4 | |
| Misalignment Detection | Strategic deception Bloom behaviors (in-distribution) | AUROC0.817 | 4 | |
| Misalignment Detection | All datasets 9 5 in-dist + 4 OOD (pooled) | AUROC93 | 4 | |
| Misalignment Detection | Sycophancy Bloom behaviors (in-distribution) | AUROC93 | 4 |